Lab accepting new cases ·  Mon–Fri, 9am–5:30pm Urgent? Call 01273 964902
BDR Brighton Data Recovery 01273 964902 Start a case
BDR / Court and investigations / Witness reports

Evidence & investigations · expert witness & reports

Expert witness reports, Brighton. Our duty is to the court. Even when you’d rather it wasn’t.

An expert report is not an advocacy document with exhibits attached. Under the civil rules, the expert's duty to the court supersedes any obligations to the person who instructed them or paid for them, and a report that doesn't recognise this is worth less than no report at all. That is why we draft our reports accordingly. Brighton solicitors instruct this bench directly, and the report is drafted to comply with CPR Part 35 from the first page to the last.

Court-ready reports — CPR 35 / CrimPR 19 Documented chain of custody Independent & confidential

Talk it through, in confidence
01273 964902

What a court-ready report contains.

The duty, stated and meantTechnical experts engaged by parties involved in civil litigation assist the courts on issues related to their areas of expertise. This duty of assistance to the court supersedes any obligation owed to the instructing or paying party. Therefore, this duty will be addressed in the first sentence of the report and will serve as the basis for assessing compliance with all other requirements.
Statements of truth and complianceThe report identifies which matters fall within the expert's own knowledge and confirms that these are true, that the opinions provided are complete professional opinions, and that it complies with Part 35 and its accompanying guidance.
Methodology and chain of custodyDetail is provided of what was received, how it was imaged/hashed/examined and where all exhibits have been located for reference purposes so that other experts may trace them back.
Disclosure — including oursSince criminal procedure was changed in 2019, disclosure must include any information capable of affecting an expert's credibility, specifically including a lack of accreditation. We state ours up front, each time.

Which report does your matter need?

Not sure? Ask us →
The reportWhat it's forWhat it includes
Findings reportInternal decisions / HR processes / early adviceSummary of findings / plain-English conclusions / method summary
Insurer / loss reportClaims / quantum / cause questionsAll findings along with cause analyses and supporting documents
CPR Part 35 reportCivil litigation in England & WalesOur duty to the court, statements of truth and compliance, full methodology, instructions summarised
CrimPR Part 19 reportCriminal proceedingsThe same as above applies to criminal rules: qualifications, reliability information, credibility disclosure
Single joint expertWhen the court directs one expert for both sidesSame report answerable to both parties & the court
Getting it to us from Brighton: first, get a price quote via phone or through our website form, then send your devices and drives via tracked and fully insured postal service to our intake laboratory in Guildford, where they will be processed. Or you may take your items to the lab in person, Monday to Friday, 9am to 5:30pm (no appointment needed). Return postage will be paid for by us. Unsure of how best to send the items? Call us and we will advise you on the safest route for your matter. We do not collect. See Contact Information.

How an expert witness report is built, stage by stage.

See recent cases →
01

Scoped in confidence, quoted in writing Free

Each instruction begins with a private discussion: What occurred? Which equipment and accounts are involved? And what question does the evidence need to answer? You will get a fixed written quotation prior to starting any examination, and there is no cost for the initial review of the scope of work.

Confidential scopingFixed written quoteClear question defined
02

Instruct and disclose

Instructions are recorded and summarised in the report. Anything bearing on our credibility (including that we are an independent non-accredited lab) is disclosed before a word of analysis is written.

Instructions on the recordStatus disclosed up front
03

Examine to the duty

The examination is run and written up as if the other side's expert were watching, because eventually they will be. Our findings read the same whether or not it was you who instructed us.

Duty to the courtFindings as found
04

Report to the rules

Each report is constructed to comply with either CPR Part 35 or CrimPR Part 19, so it includes our methodology, the exhibits, chain of custody details and statements of truth and compliance, with plain English set out above the technical appendix.

CPR 35 / CrimPR 19 formatPlain English first
05

Delivered, preserved, defensible

Upon completion of the examination you will obtain the results of the investigation (report, exhibits and supporting documentation) complete with hashes, continuity records, and our contemporaneous record of activities. In the event the work is challenged by another professional or a tribunal, all of the relevant information required to support our findings will remain available for their use.

Report + exhibitsHashes & continuity keptReady if challenged

What the lab holds to

  • The duty clause isn't boilerplate; civil rules state it bluntly: the expert's obligation to the court takes priority over any obligations to those who hire or pay them.
  • Criminal reports must carry reliability information: qualifications, experience and anything else the court needs to determine whether the opinion is reliable.
  • Single joint experts change the geometry: one expert, two parties. No cheering section. We take their instructions.
  • Plain English is a compliance feature: a report that a tribunal cannot follow will help nobody regardless of what is in its appendix.

The disclosure rule worth knowing before you instruct anyone: since April 2019, the criminal procedure directions have mandated parties disclose matters capable of undermining an expert’s reliability (including lack of accreditation) and have named this specifically. Any expert that buries this has built your case on sand; ours goes on page one.

From the casebook.

EX · BDR-2026-0534CHECKED ✓

A Part 35 report that shortened a Sussex dispute

Two businesses, one deleted folder, two competing narratives. The data from the imaged hard disk did not support either party's preferred narrative, as stated in the report and evidenced by the timeline. This case resolved within a month after the report was exchanged.

Settled post-exchangeCPR 35 compliant

Before the exhibits for your report reach us.

Do

  • Inform us at instruction whether court is possible as this impacts all aspects of the work we undertake
  • Send us the letter of instruction prior to commencing any work
  • Give us the opposing side's expert questions if there are any
  • Allow time: rigorous analysis takes time; reporting takes longer than analysis

Don't

  • Ask for conclusions from your experts before the evidence exists to support them
  • Edit your experts' findings; challenge them instead on the evidence
  • Instruct us late in the process and expect to receive a Part 35 report by Friday
  • Shop around for an expert who will 'say the right thing'; courts can see through this

Asked in confidence, answered honestly.

What's the difference between a forensic report and an expert witness report?

A findings report details what has been discovered and how. A court report goes further and includes the overriding duty to the court, statements of truth and compliance, summarised instructions, full methodology and chain of custody, plus disclosure of any information that may affect credibility.

Who does an expert witness actually work for?

Officially: the court. It is the duty to assist the court that takes precedence over any other obligations the expert has to either the instructing party or the paying party; this is exactly why it’s worth producing a compliant report.

Can you act as a single joint expert?

Yes, wherever the judge directs a single joint expert, we produce our reports to both parties under identical terms, which helps to bring everyone's focus together.

Will your non-accreditation be a problem in court?

It will be disclosed as per the rules, and weighed alongside methodology; this is ultimately where reports are judged (or fail). What harms experts is making claims they cannot substantiate; we do not.

Evidence doesn't wait. Neither should you.

Loops destroy data, artefacts age and eventually deadlines expire. Open a case first: the initial scoping call is free and confidential either way.

01273 964902